{
  "id": "judgmentkit-first-use-repair-loop-v1",
  "release_target": "0.6.5",
  "target_time_minutes": 10,
  "claim": "Install JudgmentKit, review a generated UI candidate, repair the failed contract area, and resubmit to acceptance.",
  "brief": "A support lead is reviewing refund requests during the daily triage workflow. The activity is deciding whether a case should be approved, sent to policy review, or returned to the agent for missing evidence. The outcome is a clear handoff with the next action and the reason for the decision.",
  "implementation_contract_input": {
    "repo_name": "first-use-refund-review",
    "target_stack": "React",
    "approved_primitives": [
      "FormField",
      "TextField",
      "TextArea",
      "SelectField",
      "CheckboxGroup",
      "CheckboxOption",
      "FieldGrid",
      "ModalActions"
    ],
    "static_rules": [
      "npm test"
    ],
    "browser_qa_checks": [
      "desktop viewport screenshot",
      "mobile viewport screenshot"
    ]
  },
  "failing_candidate": {
    "description": "Raw generated admin surface for refund escalation review.",
    "code": "renderRefundAdminConsole({ FormField, TextArea, CheckboxGroup, ModalActions })",
    "primitives_used": [
      "FormField",
      "TextArea",
      "CheckboxGroup",
      "CheckboxOption",
      "ModalActions"
    ],
    "states_covered": [
      "empty",
      "ready",
      "loading",
      "error",
      "disabled",
      "focus-visible"
    ],
    "static_checks": [
      "npm test"
    ],
    "browser_qa": {
      "desktop": "desktop viewport screenshot checked",
      "mobile": "mobile viewport screenshot checked"
    },
    "accessibility_evidence": {
      "automated_checks": {
        "status": "pass",
        "method": "axe smoke check",
        "notes": "No automated violations in the reviewed states."
      },
      "semantic_content": {
        "status": "pass",
        "method": "manual DOM inspection",
        "notes": "The queue, evidence review, decision reason, and handoff receipt use semantic regions."
      },
      "landmarks_headings": {
        "status": "pass",
        "method": "keyboard and screen reader outline inspection",
        "notes": "Main, review, evidence, decision, and receipt headings support orientation."
      },
      "name_role_value": {
        "status": "pass",
        "method": "browser accessibility tree inspection",
        "notes": "Decision controls expose names, roles, checked state, and disabled reasons."
      },
      "keyboard_navigation": {
        "status": "pass",
        "method": "manual keyboard pass",
        "notes": "The support lead can review evidence, select an outcome, enter a reason, and submit by keyboard."
      },
      "focus_order": {
        "status": "pass",
        "method": "tab order inspection",
        "notes": "Focus follows queue, evidence, decision, reason, and receipt order."
      },
      "focus_visible": {
        "status": "pass",
        "method": "browser focus inspection",
        "notes": "Focus remains visible on all controls."
      },
      "responsive_no_overflow": {
        "status": "pass",
        "method": "desktop and 390px viewport checks",
        "notes": "Long labels and reasons wrap without horizontal overflow."
      },
      "non_text_contrast": {
        "status": "pass",
        "method": "computed contrast review",
        "notes": "Checkbox indicators and decision states meet 3:1 non-text contrast."
      },
      "target_size": {
        "status": "pass",
        "method": "pointer target inspection",
        "notes": "Decision controls and modal actions meet minimum target size or spacing exceptions."
      },
      "focus_not_obscured": {
        "status": "pass",
        "method": "modal keyboard inspection",
        "notes": "The confirmation panel never covers focused controls."
      },
      "no_keyboard_trap": {
        "status": "pass",
        "method": "modal keyboard inspection",
        "notes": "Focus can leave the decision confirmation by standard keyboard methods."
      },
      "form_labels_instructions": {
        "status": "pass",
        "method": "label and instruction inspection",
        "notes": "Decision reason and evidence check fields have visible labels and instructions."
      },
      "form_errors": {
        "status": "pass",
        "method": "validation state inspection",
        "notes": "Reason-required and incomplete-evidence validation states name the field and next correction."
      },
      "status_messages": {
        "status": "pass",
        "method": "aria-live inspection",
        "notes": "Save, loading, error, and handoff receipt updates are announced without moving focus."
      },
      "semantic_fallbacks": {
        "status": "pass",
        "method": "DOM inspection",
        "notes": "Semantic HTML provides fallback structure for rendered content."
      }
    },
    "actions": [
      "Approve refund",
      "Send to policy review",
      "Return for evidence"
    ],
    "modal_actions": [
      {
        "context": "refund decision confirmation",
        "order": [
          "Cancel",
          "Submit decision"
        ],
        "primary_action": "Submit decision",
        "primary_position": "last"
      }
    ],
    "action_boundary_evidence": {
      "approval_boundary": "Approve refund requires explicit user confirmation and a decision reason before submission.",
      "completion_receipt": "Completion leaves a handoff receipt with the selected outcome, reason, and unresolved evidence."
    },
    "visible_text": [
      "Refund case data model",
      "JSON schema",
      "API endpoint status",
      "Prompt template",
      "Approve refund",
      "Send to policy review"
    ],
    "data_visibility_evidence": {
      "primary_data_roles": [
        "work item identity",
        "domain evidence",
        "decision options",
        "handoff receipt"
      ]
    },
    "design_system_provenance": {
      "source": "judgmentkit_default",
      "token_source": "/design-system/visual-token-adapter.json",
      "typography_source": "/design-system/visual-token-adapter.json",
      "icon_source": "JudgmentKit icon catalog via get_icon_svg",
      "renderer_component_source": "implementation_contract.default_ai_native_design_system.component_contracts",
      "import_boundary": "No visual, typography, icon, or component package imports outside the active design-system source.",
      "token_prefix_source": "implementation_contract.design_system_source.token_prefixes",
      "source_exports": "implementation_contract.design_system_source.source_exports"
    }
  },
  "repaired_candidate": {
    "description": "Refund review workspace with diagnostic implementation detail removed from the product surface.",
    "code": "renderRefundReviewWorkspace({ FormField, TextArea, CheckboxGroup, ModalActions })",
    "primitives_used": [
      "FormField",
      "TextArea",
      "CheckboxGroup",
      "CheckboxOption",
      "ModalActions"
    ],
    "states_covered": [
      "empty",
      "ready",
      "loading",
      "error",
      "disabled",
      "focus-visible"
    ],
    "static_checks": [
      "npm test"
    ],
    "browser_qa": {
      "desktop": "desktop viewport screenshot checked",
      "mobile": "mobile viewport screenshot checked"
    },
    "accessibility_evidence": {
      "automated_checks": {
        "status": "pass",
        "method": "axe smoke check",
        "notes": "No automated violations in the reviewed states."
      },
      "semantic_content": {
        "status": "pass",
        "method": "manual DOM inspection",
        "notes": "The queue, evidence review, decision reason, and handoff receipt use semantic regions."
      },
      "landmarks_headings": {
        "status": "pass",
        "method": "keyboard and screen reader outline inspection",
        "notes": "Main, review, evidence, decision, and receipt headings support orientation."
      },
      "name_role_value": {
        "status": "pass",
        "method": "browser accessibility tree inspection",
        "notes": "Decision controls expose names, roles, checked state, and disabled reasons."
      },
      "keyboard_navigation": {
        "status": "pass",
        "method": "manual keyboard pass",
        "notes": "The support lead can review evidence, select an outcome, enter a reason, and submit by keyboard."
      },
      "focus_order": {
        "status": "pass",
        "method": "tab order inspection",
        "notes": "Focus follows queue, evidence, decision, reason, and receipt order."
      },
      "focus_visible": {
        "status": "pass",
        "method": "browser focus inspection",
        "notes": "Focus remains visible on all controls."
      },
      "responsive_no_overflow": {
        "status": "pass",
        "method": "desktop and 390px viewport checks",
        "notes": "Long labels and reasons wrap without horizontal overflow."
      },
      "non_text_contrast": {
        "status": "pass",
        "method": "computed contrast review",
        "notes": "Checkbox indicators and decision states meet 3:1 non-text contrast."
      },
      "target_size": {
        "status": "pass",
        "method": "pointer target inspection",
        "notes": "Decision controls and modal actions meet minimum target size or spacing exceptions."
      },
      "focus_not_obscured": {
        "status": "pass",
        "method": "modal keyboard inspection",
        "notes": "The confirmation panel never covers focused controls."
      },
      "no_keyboard_trap": {
        "status": "pass",
        "method": "modal keyboard inspection",
        "notes": "Focus can leave the decision confirmation by standard keyboard methods."
      },
      "form_labels_instructions": {
        "status": "pass",
        "method": "label and instruction inspection",
        "notes": "Decision reason and evidence check fields have visible labels and instructions."
      },
      "form_errors": {
        "status": "pass",
        "method": "validation state inspection",
        "notes": "Reason-required and incomplete-evidence validation states name the field and next correction."
      },
      "status_messages": {
        "status": "pass",
        "method": "aria-live inspection",
        "notes": "Save, loading, error, and handoff receipt updates are announced without moving focus."
      },
      "semantic_fallbacks": {
        "status": "pass",
        "method": "DOM inspection",
        "notes": "Semantic HTML provides fallback structure for rendered content."
      }
    },
    "actions": [
      "Approve refund",
      "Send to policy review",
      "Return for evidence"
    ],
    "modal_actions": [
      {
        "context": "refund decision confirmation",
        "order": [
          "Cancel",
          "Submit decision"
        ],
        "primary_action": "Submit decision",
        "primary_position": "last"
      }
    ],
    "action_boundary_evidence": {
      "approval_boundary": "Approve refund requires explicit user confirmation and a decision reason before submission.",
      "completion_receipt": "Completion leaves a handoff receipt with the selected outcome, reason, and unresolved evidence."
    },
    "visible_text": [
      "Refund request",
      "Evidence checklist",
      "Decision reason",
      "Approve refund",
      "Send to policy review",
      "Return for evidence",
      "Handoff receipt"
    ],
    "data_visibility_evidence": {
      "primary_data_roles": [
        "work item identity",
        "domain evidence",
        "decision options",
        "handoff receipt"
      ]
    },
    "design_system_provenance": {
      "source": "judgmentkit_default",
      "token_source": "/design-system/visual-token-adapter.json",
      "typography_source": "/design-system/visual-token-adapter.json",
      "icon_source": "JudgmentKit icon catalog via get_icon_svg",
      "renderer_component_source": "implementation_contract.default_ai_native_design_system.component_contracts",
      "import_boundary": "No visual, typography, icon, or component package imports outside the active design-system source.",
      "token_prefix_source": "implementation_contract.design_system_source.token_prefixes",
      "source_exports": "implementation_contract.design_system_source.source_exports"
    }
  },
  "transcript": [
    {
      "attempt": 1,
      "agent_action": "review",
      "expected_next_agent_action": "repair_and_resubmit",
      "failed_contract_area": "data_visibility",
      "agent_repair": "Replace implementation-language primary labels with refund review language."
    },
    {
      "attempt": 2,
      "agent_action": "resubmit",
      "expected_next_agent_action": "accept",
      "result": "The repaired candidate keeps implementation mechanics out of the primary product surface."
    }
  ]
}